I've decided I'm done Don't care to move on Not used to losing someone If I lost fate Was no choice I made Accept the excuse of no one Your careful silence can't replace your stupid smile Casseroles and handshakes can't restore Twelve damn years of ours You stole me I don't dare to try again They said time will heal And time will mend But on Halloween The last time you left If I knew you were never coming back I would've held on to that last day Instead of 'here's your keys' The last thing I'd say would be 'I love you' Just in case I'm only myself when I'm with you, baby Take down my mirror My pictures of costumes and you Put aside posters and books and aged fortunes And all this reminds me of you With a pat on the back they say "honey, it's time to move on I'm sure we can find you a hobby now that he's gone" I stole you I don't dare to try again They said time will heal And time will mend But on Halloween The last time you left If I knew you were never coming back I would've held on to that last day Instead of 'here's your keys' The last thing I'd say would be 'I love you' Just in case I'm only myself when I'm with you, baby They don't understand We were like this since the first time we met We were born holding hands Give me flowers and cards I'll smile all they want If they give me what I want Please give me what I want! I don't dare to try again They said time will heal And time will mend But on Halloween The last time you left If I knew you were never coming back I would've held on to that last day Instead of 'here's your keys' The last thing I'd say would be 'I love you' Just in case I'm only myself when I'm with you, baby I'll be with you someday